Mango Markets 回购计划引发社区争议

4 月 7 日向 Mango Markets DAO 提出的一项颇具争议的 MNGO 代币回购计划引发了社区内部的指责。批评者称，该计划有利于 FTX MNGO 储备的匿名买家，并猜测买家可能在提出回购之前以低价购买了这些代币。尽管遭到反对，该计划的修订版还是于 4 月 24 日获得批准，引发了关于对代币持有者和协议财务未来影响的争论。

Community Contention Over Mango Markets Token Buyback Plan

社区对 Mango Markets 代币回购计划的争论

Prelude

序幕

On April 7, 2023, a proposed token buyback plan within the decentralized autonomous organization (DAO) governing Mango Markets, a Solana-based Web3 lending and borrowing protocol, sparked controversy. The plan, proposed by Mango DAO member DonDuala, entailed the DAO repurchasing 275 million MNGO tokens from its current holders, offering 9.995 million CHAI stablecoin derivatives in exchange. The implied buyback price of $0.032 per MNGO token significantly exceeded the market price of $0.02324 at the time.

2023 年 4 月 7 日，管理 Mango Markets（基于 Solana 的 Web3 借贷协议）的去中心化自治组织 (DAO) 内提出的代币回购计划引发了争议。该计划由 Mango DAO 成员 DonDuala 提出，要求 DAO 从现有持有者手中回购 2.75 亿个 MNGO 代币，并提供 999.5 万个 CHAI 稳定币衍生品作为交换。每个 MNGO 代币的隐含回购价格为 0.032 美元，大大超过了当时 0.02324 美元的市场价格。

Community Concerns

社区关注

Scrutiny arose when it was discovered that a mysterious account had received a large quantity of MNGO tokens from the estate of bankrupt crypto exchange FTX shortly before the buyback proposal was introduced. Community member Donderper expressed concerns that this account may have acquired the tokens through an over-the-counter deal at a significantly lower price than the proposed buyback price, potentially netting a substantial profit.

在回购提案提出前不久，有人发现一个神秘账户从破产的加密货币交易所 FTX 的财产中收到了大量 MNGO 代币，从而引起了密切关注。社区成员 Donderper 表示担心，该账户可能通过场外交易以远低于拟议回购价格的价格购买了代币，从而可能获得可观的利润。

Allegations of Collusion

共谋指控

Further suspicions were raised when some community members suggested that DonDuala and another DAO member, Maximilian, might be affiliated with the FTX-related account. These accusations were based on the account using its tokens to vote in favor of the buyback proposal. DonDuala, however, sidestepped questions about potential connections and instead emphasized the benefits of supporting the proposal.

当一些社区成员暗示 DonDuala 和另一位 DAO 成员 Maximilian 可能与 FTX 相关账户有关联时，引发了进一步的怀疑。这些指控是基于该账户使用其代币投票支持回购提案。然而，唐杜阿拉回避了有关潜在联系的问题，而是强调了支持该提案的好处。

Proposal Failure and Resubmission

提案失败和重新提交

The initial proposal was rejected by a majority vote, leading DonDuala to resubmit it with amendments. The revised proposal reduced the buyback amount to 156 million MNGO and expanded the distribution of options to all users who had interacted with the DAO's governance system.

最初的提案被多数票否决，导致 DonDuala 重新提交修正案。修订后的提案将回购金额减少至 1.56 亿个 MNGO，并将期权分配范围扩大到所有与 DAO 治理系统互动的用户。

Opposition and Legal Issues

反对和法律问题

Despite these adjustments, opposition to the plan persisted. Mango Markets co-founder Daffy Durairaj alleged that DonDuala and Maximilian were acting in their financial self-interest and engaging in manipulative behavior. Additionally, Durairaj pointed to the recent legal troubles of Avrham Eisenberg, who had been found guilty of fraud and possession of child pornography in connection with the Mango Markets exploit in October 2022.

尽管进行了这些调整，对该计划的反对依然存在。 Mango Markets 联合创始人 Daffy Durairaj 声称，DonDuala 和 Maximilian 的行为是出于自身财务利益，并参与操纵行为。此外，Durairaj 还指出了 Avrham Eisenberg 最近的法律麻烦，他因 2022 年 10 月的 Mango Markets 漏洞利用而被判犯有欺诈和持有儿童色情制品罪。

Proposal Approval and Execution

提案批准与执行

Despite the objections, the amended proposal ultimately passed on April 24, with over 67.9% of tokens voting in favor. Subsequently, the DAO purchased approximately 73 million MNGO tokens for 2.3 million CHAI.

尽管遭到反对，修改后的提案最终于 4 月 24 日获得通过，超过 67.9% 的代币投了赞成票。随后，DAO 用 230 万个 CHAI 购买了约 7300 万个 MNGO 代币。

Ongoing Concerns

持续关注

While the proposed buyback plan has been executed, concerns persist within the Mango Markets community. Members have expressed dissatisfaction with the perceived lack of transparency and potential conflicts of interest surrounding the buyback process. The fallout from the Mango Markets exploit and the legal proceedings against Eisenberg continue to cast a shadow over the protocol and its governance.

虽然拟议的回购计划已经执行，但 Mango Markets 社区内部仍然存在担忧。成员们对回购过程缺乏透明度和潜在利益冲突表示不满。 Mango Markets 漏洞的影响和针对艾森伯格的法律诉讼继续给该协议及其治理蒙上阴影。

Implications for Community Governance

对社区治理的影响

The Mango Markets token buyback episode highlights the challenges and complexities of decentralized governance in Web3 projects. The incident has raised questions about the transparency, accountability, and potential for conflicts of interest within DAO decision-making processes. It remains to be seen how the Mango Markets community will address these issues and rebuild trust moving forward.

Mango Markets 代币回购事件凸显了 Web3 项目中去中心化治理的挑战和复杂性。该事件引发了人们对 DAO 决策过程中的透明度、问责制以及潜在利益冲突的质疑。 Mango Markets 社区将如何解决这些问题并重建信任，还有待观察。