加密交易所Coinbase（Coin）首席法律官Paul Grewal批评了美国财政部最近的备案

加密交易所Coinbase（Coin）首席法律官Paul Grewal批评了美国财政部最近提交的文件，该文件旨在提出关于龙卷风现金的最终法院判决的必要性

Paul Grewal, chief legal officer at crypto exchange Coinbase (COIN), criticized the U.S. Treasury's recent filing that seeks to moot the necessity of a final court judgment regarding Tornado Cash after having delisted the crypto mixer from the sanctions list.

加密货币交易所Coinbase（Coin）首席法律官Paul Grewal批评了美国财政部最近的文件，该文件旨在在从制裁名单中删除加密货币混音器后，要求对龙卷风现金进行最终法院判决。

The Treasury argued that its action of delisting Tornado Cash from the Specially Designated Nationals list on Friday had rendered the issue at hand moot and that a final court ruling ordering it to remove the crypto mixer from its sanctions list was no longer necessary, according to a court filing dated March 21.

该财政部认为，它在周五将龙卷风现金从特殊指定的国民名单中提取龙卷风现金的行动使该问题提出了辩论，并且最终的法院裁定命令将其从其制裁清单中删除加密货币搅拌机，这是不再需要从其制裁清单中删除的。

However, Grewal said the Treasury's attempts to have the case declared moot is an attempt to sidestep a ruling from the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals that will leave the door open for a renewed blacklisting and sanctions.

然而，格雷瓦尔说，财政部试图宣布案件的企图是试图避开第五巡回上诉法院的裁决，该裁决将使新的黑名单和制裁均可敞开大门。

"After grudgingly delisting TC, they now claim they've mooted any need for a final court judgment. But that's not the law, and they know it. As the Supreme Court explained in Church & State v. Reals, 'a defendant's decision to cease challenged conduct renders a case moot only if the defendant can show that the conduct cannot "reasonably be expected to recur."' Grewal said on X.

“在勉强地幻想着TC之后，他们声称他们对最终法院的判决有任何需求。但这不是法律，他们知道。正如最高法院在教堂与州诉皇家案中解释的那样，'被告决定停止挑战行为的决定才能使被告的案件提出诉讼，只有被告才能表明该行为不能表明“合理地说“对“居住”的行为，否则是恢复的。

Coinbase funded the court case that made its way to the appeals court, Van Loon vs. Treasury. The case began in 2022 after the Treasury sanctioned Tornado Cash and its founder, and the exchange argued that the move was unlawful.

Coinbase资助了向上诉法院，Van Loon与财政部的法院案件。该案始于2022年，财政部批准了Tornado Cash及其创始人，交易所认为此举是非法的。

Grewal said the Treasury's argument is an attempt to avoid a ruling on the merits of the case, which will leave the door open for the administration to re-sanction Tornado Cash.

格雷瓦尔说，财政部的论点是试图避免对案件的裁决做出裁决，这将使政府为重新裁定龙卷风现金开放。

"We're grateful to the court for recognizing the absurdity of Treasury's attempt to use its own unlawful conduct to avoid a ruling from the Fifth Circuit on the merits of the case. As the court noted, 'the fact that the agency's conduct in this case was unlawful is not a new legal theory that the court should avoid addressing.'

“我们感谢法院承认财政部试图使用其非法行为避免根据案件的裁决来避免裁定第五巡回法院的裁决。正如法院指出的那样，“这种情况下，该机构的行为是非法的，这不是法院应避免解决的事实。”

Coinbase’s attorneys at Miller Canetti advised the exchange on the case.

Coinbase在Miller Canetti的律师就案件的交流建议。