Ammclawback修正案在XRP Ledger上激发了权力下放辩论

XRP分类帐（XRPL）上的Ammclawback修正案的激活引发了围绕网络权力下放的辩论。

The recent activation of the AMMClawback amendment on the XRP Ledger (XRPL) has sparked a lively debate within the XRP community regarding the network's decentralization. On January 30, 2025, the amendment was integrated into the XRPL, paving the way for tokens with clawback capabilities, such as Ripple's RLUSD stablecoin, to be traded within Automated Market Maker (AMM) pools on the XRP Ledger Decentralized Exchange (DEX). Previously, the network had prohibited tokens with clawback features from participating in these pools. This change marks a significant development in enhancing liquidity on the XRPL.

XRP Ledger（XRPL）对Ammclawback修正案的最新激活引发了XRP社区中有关网络权力下放化的生动辩论。 2025年1月30日，该修正案被整合到XRPL中，为带有回扣功能的代币铺平了道路，例如Ripple的Rlusd Stablecoin，将在自动化市政市场制造商（AMM）池中进行交易。以前，该网络禁止具有回击功能的令牌参与这些池。这种变化标志着增强XRPL流动性的重大发展。

However, not everyone is convinced that this amendment aligns with the decentralized nature of the XRP Ledger. Wendy O, a renowned market commentator and host of The O Show, publicly voiced her concerns about the change, suggesting that the activation of the AMMClawback amendment makes the XRPL more centralized. Wendy's remarks have sparked discussions throughout the XRP community, with proponents of decentralization seeking to clarify how the clawback feature works and its impact on the XRPL's consensus model.

但是，并不是每个人都相信这项修正案与XRP分类帐的分散性质保持一致。著名的市场评论员和O展览的主持人温迪·奥（Wendy O）公开表达了她对这一变化的担忧，这表明Ammclawback修正案的激活使XRPL更加集中。温迪的言论引发了整个XRP社区的讨论，支持权力下放的支持者寻求阐明回扣功能的工作方式及其对XRPL共识模型的影响。

Wendy O Claims XRPL Is No Longer Decentralized

Wendy O声称XRPL不再分散

Wendy O expressed her concerns about the AMMClawback amendment, arguing that the introduction of the feature indicates a move towards centralization. According to Wendy, the fact that the amendment allows tokens with clawback features to be traded on AMM pools contradicts the core principles of decentralization. She further questioned whether the community fully understood the implications of the feature.

温迪·奥（Wendy O）表示她对Ammclawback修正案的担忧，认为该功能的引入表明了朝着集中化的行动。根据温迪（Wendy）的说法，该修正案允许在AMM池上交易的代币与权力下放的核心原则相矛盾。她进一步质疑社区是否完全了解该功能的含义。

Despite her reservations, Wendy confirmed that she had thoroughly covered the topic but maintained that the amendment undermines the decentralized ideals that XRP was founded upon.

尽管她保留了她的保留，但温迪确认她已经彻底介绍了这个话题，但坚持认为，修正案破坏了XRP建立的分散理想。

Moon Lambo Defends XRPL’s Decentralized Nature

月亮兰博捍卫XRPL的分散自然

In response to Wendy O's claims, Moon Lambo, a prominent figure in the XRP community, stepped forward to refute the accusation that the XRPL has become centralized. Moon Lambo emphasized that the clawback feature does not impact XRP itself and does not alter the decentralized nature of the XRPL.

为了回应Wendy O的主张，XRP社区中的著名人物Moon Lambo迈出了驳斥XRPL已成为集中的指控。 Moon Lambo强调，回击功能不会影响XRP本身，也不会改变XRPL的分散性。

He explained that decentralization is defined by the freedom of participants to create tokens with various features, including the ability to enable clawbacks. If a central authority restricted users from issuing such tokens, that would represent true centralization. However, as long as participants can issue tokens with specific functions, the XRP Ledger remains decentralized.

他解释说，权力下放是由参与者自由创建具有各种特征的令牌的自由，包括启用回扣的能力。如果中央当局限制用户发行这种代币，则代表真正的集中化。但是，只要参与者可以发出特定功能的代币，XRP Ledger仍将分散。

Moon Lambo also highlighted that the amendment's approval process, in which more than 80% of validators supported the change over two weeks, adhered to XRPL's decentralized governance model. The validator voting system, which determines changes to the ledger, remains intact, further reinforcing the network's decentralized foundation.

月亮兰博还强调说，该修正案的批准过程，其中80％以上的验证者在两周内支持了这一变化，并遵守XRPL的分散治理模型。确定分类账的变化的验证者投票系统仍然完好无损，进一步加强了网络的分散基础。

Clawback Feature: What It Really Means for Token Issuers

回击功能：这对令牌发行人的意义

The clawback feature allows token issuers to reclaim tokens under certain conditions, often to meet regulatory requirements. However, this feature applies only to issued tokens, not to the XRP token or the overall network. Moon Lambo used an analogy to further explain that having control over one's personal wallet does not mean controlling the entire blockchain. Similarly, Ripple has control over the issuance and management of RLUSD but does not control XRP or the broader XRPL ecosystem.

回击功能允许令牌发行人在某些条件下收回令牌，通常以满足监管要求。但是，此功能仅适用于发行的令牌，而不适用于XRP令牌或整个网络。月亮兰博（Moon Lambo）用一个类比来进一步解释，控制个人钱包并不意味着控制整个区块链。同样，Ripple可以控制RLUSD的发行和管理，但不能控制XRP或更广泛的XRPL生态系统。

This distinction is crucial for understanding why the clawback feature does not compromise the decentralized nature of XRP. Token issuers can manage their assets as they see fit, but they do not have the authority to change the rules of the network or override the validator consensus that governs XRPL's decentralized operation.

这种区别对于理解为什么回击特征不会损害XRP的分散性质至关重要。代币发行人可以在他们认为合适的情况下管理其资产，但是他们无权更改网络规则或覆盖管理XRPL分散操作的验证者共识。

XLS-39 and XLS-73 Amendments: Key Features for Issued Tokens

XLS-39和XLS-73修订：发行令牌的主要功能

The XLS-39 amendment, which was introduced in February 2024, laid the groundwork for enabling the clawback functionality for issued tokens. Under this amendment, issuers must decide whether to implement the clawback feature at the time of the asset's issuance.

XLS-39修正案于2024年2月推出，为发行的代币提供了回扣功能的基础。根据该修正案，发行人必须决定在资产发行时是否实施回扣功能。

The XLS-73 amendment, which became active in January 2025, allowed tokens with the clawback feature to interact with AMM pools, while ensuring that frozen tokens cannot enter these pools to comply with regulations. These amendments specifically apply to issued assets that require trustlines, such as RLUSD. Notably, XRP does not require a trustline and, as such, is unaffected by these changes.

XLS-73修正案于2025年1月开始活跃，允许具有Clawback功能的令牌与AMM池相互作用，同时确保冷冻令牌不能进入这些池以遵守法规。这些修正案专门适用于需要信任的发行资产，例如RLUSD。值得注意的是，XRP不需要信任线，因此不受这些变化的影响。

Debunking the Centralization Myth

揭穿集中化神话

WrathofKahneman (WOK), another prominent member of the XRP community, further clarified that although certain issued tokens, such as RLUSD, may have centralized features, it does not imply that XRPL itself is centralized. WOK emphasized that the XRP Ledger continues to be designed to support a variety of financial models, enabling a broad range of assets with varying levels of centralization.

XRP社区的另一位杰出成员Wrathofkahneman（Wok）进一步澄清说，尽管某些发行的令牌（例如RLUSD）可能具有集中的特征，但这并不意味着XRPL本身是集中的。 Wok强调，XRP Ledger继续设计为支持各种财务模型，从而使广泛的资产具有不同的集中化水平。

The XRPL itself remains decentralized, as evidenced by the community-driven governance model, which allows validators to vote on changes to the ledger, including amendments like AMMClawback. This decentralized governance ensures that no single entity can control the network or alter its underlying principles.

正如社区驱动的治理模型所证明的那样，XRPL本身仍然是分散的，该模型允许验证者对分类帐更改进行投票，包括诸如Ammclawback之类的修正案。这种分散的治理可确保没有一个实体可以控制网络或改变其基本原则。

The Future of Decentralization on the XRP Ledger

XRP分类帐中权力下放的未来

The discussions surrounding the AMMClawback

围绕Ammclawback的讨论