|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Cryptocurrency News Articles
Does SBF’s Appeal Stand a Chance of Succeeding?
Sep 20, 2024 at 04:05 am
Lawyers contacted by CoinDesk are skeptical the FTX’s founder will get another trial.
Sam Bankman-Fried filed an appeal to the Second Circuit Court of Appeals on Friday, Sept. 13, arguing that he was unfairly treated at trial, which took place as public scrutiny of the FTX case reached a fever pitch.
His new lead lawyer, Alexandra Shapiro, argues in the appeal that SBF was “presumed guilty by federal prosecutors eager for quick headlines,” “presumed guilty by the judge who presided over his trial,” and that the “prevailing narrative” of FTX’s collapse, and SBF’s part in it, was accepted as true, without proper inquiry.
“From day one, the prevailing narrative—initially spun by the lawyers who took over FTX, quickly adopted by their contacts at the U.S. Attorney’s Office—was that Bankman-Fried had stolen billions of dollars of customer funds, driven FTX to insolvency, and caused billions in losses,” the appeal continues.
“Now, nearly two years later, a very different picture is emerging—one confirming FTX was never insolvent, and in fact had assets worth billions to repay its customers. But the jury at BankmanFried’s trial never got to see that picture.”
However, lawyers contacted by CoinDesk were skeptical that SBF would win a retrial, given the high bar for such legal turnovers.
“It’s just not very common for an appellate court to double-guess a case like this,” said Tama Beth Kudman, partner at Kudman Trachten Aloe Posner.
SBF’s lawyers would have to prove not only that Kaplan was biased against SBF, she said, and also that such bias led to actions that were prejudicial against SBF.
To allow the appeal to go forward, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals would be saying effectively that it thought the judge in the original case acted inappropriately – something it rarely does, Kudman said.
The appeals court might order a retrial if SBF's lawyers could show that Kaplan had a personal conflict of interest. But there’s no evidence for that, thus far. “Kaplan is known as a well-tempered, good natured judge. I would have thought he would have stepped aside if there was any reason that he shouldn’t be hearing the case,” Kudman said.
Joshua Ashley Klayman, the U.S. head of fintech and head of blockchain and digital assets at Linklaters, said the appeal may have been timed to coincide with sentencing for Caroline Ellison, SBF’s former colleague and sometime lover.
U.S. government lawyers have not requested jail time for Ellison, noting that the SBF case would have been “difficult to prove” without her testimony. Shapiro may be trying to juxtapose SBF’s steep sentencing with Ellison’s much lighter penalty.
“Without expressing a view on the likelihood of success of Sam Bankman-Fried’s appeal, the timing of his filing may be strategic," Klayman said. "SBF’s appeal was filed on September 13, 2024, three days after the filing of Caroline Ellison’s sentencing memorandum. SBF was sentenced to 25 years in prison, while Caroline Ellison’s counsel has requested a non-custodial sentence."
Klayman said news that FTX creditors are being repaid could help SBF's legal team.
“The mainstream media has reported on FTX’s plans to repay customers. Perhaps SBF and his counsel may hope that, with the passage of time, SBF’s arguments [that FTX customers didn’t lose money] may be viewed in a different light."
Joe Valenti, partner in the White Collar & Government Enforcement practice at law firm Saul Ewing, says appeals courts tend to give significant discretion to judges in weighing evidence, provided they meet a basic standard of reasonableness.
"Anything that's tied to the reading of the facts, or the conduct of the courtroom, they give significant leeway to the court," he said. Judges are allowed to control the courtroom in the interest of expeditious justice and limiting evidence from being admitted to the record is well within the discretion of the judge.
As for the argument that customers are being made whole in bankruptcy, Valenti doesn't see that argument holding much water either.
"It doesn't matter if the money was paid back. If you're a cashier at the supermarket and you take $20 to go to the casino, it doesn’t matter if you give back the money the next day. You still took money from the grocery store."
Disclaimer:info@kdj.com
The information provided is not trading advice. kdj.com does not assume any responsibility for any investments made based on the information provided in this article. Cryptocurrencies are highly volatile and it is highly recommended that you invest with caution after thorough research!
If you believe that the content used on this website infringes your copyright, please contact us immediately (info@kdj.com) and we will delete it promptly.
-
- Chainlink (LINK) Price Skyrockets 7% as Speculations of a Chainlink ETF Gain Traction
- Sep 20, 2024 at 12:20 pm
- Chainlink (LINK) price has gained momentum following the recent TOKEN2049 event. Moreover, speculations of a Chainlink ETF are gaining traction, especially following the launch of the Grayscale XRP trust.
-
- U.S. Election Betting: CFTC, Kalshi Both Grilled by Judges in Appeals Court
- Sep 20, 2024 at 12:20 pm
- The agency appealed a lower court's decision to let the firm offer prediction markets on which party will control each house of Congress. Crypto firms are watching the case.
-
- Ethiopia, China Formalize Currency Swap Agreement Targeting Enhanced Trade Flexibility
- Sep 20, 2024 at 12:20 pm
- This significant move, announced by Finance Minister Ahmed Shide, aims to enhance trade flexibility, attract foreign direct investment (FDI), alleviate foreign exchange shortages, and strengthen economic ties between the two nations.
-
- Cryptocurrency Whale Cashes Out $3.2M in PEPE, FLOKI, and WLD Holdings, Securing a $200K Profit
- Sep 20, 2024 at 12:20 pm
- The sell-off came after the Federal Reserve's rate cut, with traders reacting to increased market volatility.
-
- Aave (AAVE) Price Prediction: AAVE Rally Appears Imminent, But Can It Break Decisive Resistance?
- Sep 20, 2024 at 12:20 pm
- As of press time, Aave [AAVE] achieved a 6.63% rise over the past 24 hours, despite its inconsistent performance over the week. Maintaining this momentum could nullify the week's losses and position AAVE for a higher trajectory than observed in the last two weeks.
-
- AERGO Price Jumps 25%: What's After Binance Contract Launch?
- Sep 20, 2024 at 12:20 pm
- Aergo (AERGO) recently made waves as its price surged by 25%, following the announcement of Binance launching USD-margined perpetual contracts for the token.
-
- TRON and Kaspa See Big Changes, But BlockDAG Steals the Spotlight With X10 Miner and 30,000x ROI Forecast
- Sep 20, 2024 at 12:20 pm
- TRON (TRX) is currently in a retracement phase, with traders closely watching for signs of a rebound. At the same time, Kaspa (KAS) holders are hoping for a price recovery, as technical indicators suggest the coin may have hit its lowest point. Amid this uncertainty, BlockDAG is stealing the spotlight.
-
- Claim $SHIB or Stay Poor: You Decide!
- Sep 20, 2024 at 12:20 pm
- How to be eligibile Shibwifhat Airdrop: Quick Guide
-
- Bitcoin Rises Following FOMC Rate Decision
- Sep 20, 2024 at 12:20 pm
- The most recent FOMC meeting set the stage for Bitcoin's price jump of 4.42% to $62,605. The committee, in releasing the first quarter monetary policy statement, decided to reduce interest rates by 50 basis points, which influenced the market positively.