Memecoins - The inevitable path to mainstream adoption or the symptom of a broken system?

As the host of Blockchain Banter, I recently led a discussion on memecoins—a topic that has sparked intense controversy throughout the industry.

Hot Topic: Memecoins - Blessing or Curse in the Crypto World?

Original Title: "Memecoins - The inevitable path to mainstream adoption or the symptom of a broken system?"

Author: Jen Albert

Translation by: Baihua Blockchain

As the host of Blockchain Banter, I recently led a discussion on memecoins—a topic that has sparked intense controversy throughout the industry. Whether you love them or hate them, their impact cannot be denied. Some believe they are ruining the crypto industry, while others see them as a natural evolution of decentralized market development.

To delve deeper into this debate, I invited Justin Havens (Head of Ecosystem Growth at Polygon DeFi) and Dr. Mark Richardson (Head of Bancor & Carbon DeFi projects) to explore the topic together. We had an in-depth discussion around the following core topics:

This conversation revealed the multifaceted impact of memecoins in the crypto market, and you are welcome to join the discussion!

1. The Memecoin Controversy

Memecoins have caused significant division in the crypto space. Some view them as a fun and community-driven way to participate in the market, while others believe they undermine the legitimacy of the industry. On one hand, prominent figures like Benjamin Cowen have bluntly stated, "Memecoins are ruining the crypto industry."

On the other hand, we also see some industry leaders taking the opposite stance, such as CZ (Changpeng Zhao), co-founder and former CEO of Binance, who seems to encourage (or perhaps not 😏) the birth of more memecoins by posting a picture of his pet dog Broccoli along with an entire backstory.

"I just posted a photo and the name of my dog. I did not issue a memecoin myself; whether to create one is entirely up to the community (or not to create one is fine too). However, I might interact with some popular memecoins on the BNB Chain (BSC). The BNB Foundation may provide rewards for top memecoins on the BNB Chain, such as LP support or other incentives. The details are still under discussion, so stay tuned."

Justin believes that memecoins are not a random phenomenon but rather a necessary outcome of regulatory crackdowns on structured token issuance. Due to concerns about legal risks, project teams have had to choose from the following options:

So, what happens when the only viable way to issue public tokens is through tokens with no actual utility? The answer is—the rise of memecoins.

Mark further points out, "Market incentives determine the final outcome." Regulators have created an environment where utility tokens fall into a legal gray area, while tokens that explicitly claim to be "useless" face almost no compliance risks. The result is that memecoins quickly dominate the market.

2. Investor or Gambler? The Subtle Line in the Crypto Market

One of the biggest misconceptions in the crypto space is the belief that there is a clear line between investing and gambling. But does this line really exist?

Investors research fundamentals, assess risks, and make decisions with a long-term perspective.

Gamblers chase trends, trade impulsively, and accept extreme risks.

Justin points out that many retail traders are forced into a "gambling mentality" because they cannot participate in traditional early-stage investments. Unless you are an accredited investor, your only option is speculative trading—which includes memecoins.

Mark believes that this line is blurrier than most people think. After all, some of the historically best-performing crypto assets have been obvious scams. As he puts it:

"People will warn you not to invest in this, calling it a scam. While others will say, 'I know it is.'"

It is this paradox that fuels the frenzy around memecoins—projects that appear most like scams sometimes yield the greatest returns.

3. Do KOLs Fuel the Frenzy of Memecoins?

The conversation naturally turned to KOLs (Key Opinion Leaders) and paid influencers—important drivers in the memecoin ecosystem. So, is the root of the problem memecoins themselves, or those who promote them for profit?

This also explains another side of the memecoin hype—are they created by market demand, or are they artificially inflated?

4. Is the Term KOL Misused in the Crypto Space?

Mark believes that the term "KOL" is often misused in the crypto field. Many so-called "opinion leaders" are essentially just advertisers flipping token shares behind the scenes. If a project needs to pay someone to talk about it, it raises the question: why does it need to do so?

What is the core issue? Questioning the incentive mechanisms. If someone is pushing a token hard, ask yourself—what do they stand to gain from it?

5. DYOR: Is It Really Feasible?

The phrase "Do Your Own Research (DYOR)" is repeatedly emphasized in the crypto space, but the reality is often much more complex than the slogan suggests. As audience member Mike pointed out, DYOR is easier said than done.

Most people