Cardano创始人查尔斯·霍斯金森（Charles Hoskinson）作为CBDC Smalls Wyoming的Stablecoin计划

在2025年2月4日的直播中，Cardano的创始人和Input Outper Global（IOG）首席执行官查尔斯·霍斯金森（Charles Hoskinson）对怀俄明州的计划进行了鲜明的谴责

Charles Hoskinson, the founder of Cardano and CEO of Input Output Global (IOG), has strongly criticized Wyoming’s plan to develop a state-backed stablecoin, alleging that certain critical requirements were not disclosed upfront and that the process appears to favor a specific blockchain solution.

Cardano的创始人兼输入输出全球（IOG）首席执行官Charles Hoskinson强烈批评了怀俄明州制定以国家支持的Stablecoin的计划，声称没有预先披露某些关键要求，并且该过程似乎偏爱特定的区块链解决方案。 。

In a livestream on February 4, 2025, Hoskinson delivered a scathing rebuke of Wyoming’s stablecoin initiative, accusing the state of failing to follow proper procurement procedures and excluding major blockchain platforms from contention.

在2025年2月4日的一次直播中，霍斯金森对怀俄明州的Stablecoin倡议进行了严厉的斥责，指控未能遵循适当的采购程序，并将主要区块链平台排除在争夺中。

According to Hoskinson, Wyoming’s plan to create a state-backed stablecoin, which has been touted as the first of its kind in the United States, encountered several problems from the outset. He alleges that the state failed to publish or share a detailed product requirements document (PRD) that outlines key must-have features, such as the ability to freeze or seize tokens under certain legal or regulatory conditions.

根据霍斯金森（Hoskinson）的说法，怀俄明州制定一个国家支持的stablecoin的计划，该计划从一开始就遇到了几个问题。他声称，该州未能发布或共享详细的产品需求文件（PRD），概述了关键的必备功能，例如在某些法律或监管条件下冻结或扣押令牌的能力。

Hoskinson claims that this omission not only prevents fair competition but also poses risks to user privacy and broader blockchain adoption.

霍斯金森（Hoskinson）声称，这种遗漏不仅阻止了公平的竞争，而且对用户隐私和更广泛的区块链采用构成风险。

“We were told it would be an open process and we would know ahead of time what the product requirements would be,” Hoskinson says in the video. “Instead, they hid the PRD… and decided to qualify people themselves.”

霍斯金森在视频中说：“我们被告知这将是一个开放的过程，我们会提前知道产品要求是什么。” “相反，他们隐藏了PRD……并决定使自己有资格。”

He contends that Wyoming’s selection criteria were only disclosed after the fact, at which point the state allegedly gave less than five days for companies to prove they could meet the freeze-and-seize requirement. The Cardano ecosystem, he argues, could have implemented such a feature in approximately two weeks if it had been explicitly included in the PRD from the outset.

他认为，怀俄明州的选择标准只有在事实之后才披露，据称该州为公司提供了不到五天的时间，使公司证明他们可以满足冻结和易于实现的要求。他认为，如果从一开始就明确包含在PRD中，Cardano生态系统本可以在大约两周内实施此类功能。

To highlight Cardano’s capabilities, Hoskinson contrasts fully programmable blockchains like Cardano and Ethereum with so-called “fixed-function” ledgers, including XRP. Programmable chains allow developers to build new features directly into smart contracts, meaning a freeze-and-seize capability can be added if required.

为了强调Cardano的能力，Hoskinson将完全可编程的区块链与包括XRP在内的所谓“固定功能”分类帐形成了完全可编程的区块链。可编程链使开发人员可以将新功能直接构建到智能合约中，这意味着可以在需要时添加冻结和尺寸的功能。

“On Cardano or Ethereum, if there’s something the protocol doesn’t support natively, you write a smart contract,” he explains. “So, if we had known freeze-and-seize was a Hardline product requirement, we could have simply written a contract to satisfy it.”

他解释说：“在Cardano或以太坊上，如果协议本身不支持，您会写一份智能合约。” “因此，如果我们知道冻结和尺寸是一项硬线产品的要求，我们可以简单地写一份合同来满足它。”

Hoskinson points to what he calls a mischaracterization by officials overseeing Wyoming’s stablecoin project, who had stated that Cardano did not meet this criterion without clarifying the short timeline or undisclosed requirements.

霍斯金森（Hoskinson）指出了他所说的官员们负责怀俄明州的Stablecoin项目的错误表现，后者表示，如果没有澄清短时间或未公开的要求，卡达诺就不符合此标准。

Throughout the video, Hoskinson implies that the process may have been orchestrated to favor a particular blockchain solution, suggesting that one of the decision-makers previously worked with the platform being singled out for the project. He underscores that no open bidding or public discussion took place on the critical features of the stablecoin.

在整个视频中，霍斯金森（Hoskinson）表示，该过程可能已经精心策划，以偏爱特定的区块链解决方案，这表明其中一位决策者以前曾与该计划一起为该项目进行了挑选。他强调说，没有公开竞标或公众讨论就stablecoin的关键特征进行。

Hoskinson also critiques the idea that Wyoming’s stablecoin would be functionally similar to a central bank digital currency (CBDC) because of its freeze-and-seize feature and transparent ledger, warning that this undermines financial privacy. In his view, this architecture gives authorities—or even third parties—the power to monitor all transactions and freeze funds at will.

霍斯金森（Hoskinson）还批评了怀俄明州的稳定币在功能上与中央银行数字货币（CBDC）相似的想法，因为它具有冻结和透明的分类帐，并警告说这会破坏财务隐私。在他看来，这种体系结构为当局甚至第三方赋予了监视所有交易并随意冻结资金的权力。

“If you hold Wyoming stablecoin, know that everything you buy is monitored and tracked,” Hoskinson says. “At any given time, civil asset forfeiture… they can just seize it.”

霍斯金森说：“如果您持怀俄明州的稳定币，请知道您购买的所有东西都经过监控和跟踪。” “在任何给定的时间，民事资产没收……他们可以抓住它。”

He questions the logic of investing state resources to build a product that, in his estimation, competes head-on with more established players—such as Tether or Circle—which have far larger budgets and market share.

他质疑投资国家资源以建立一种产品的逻辑，该产品估计，该产品与更具成熟的参与者（例如系绳或圈子）正面竞争，该产品的预算和市场份额要大得多。

In his remarks, Hoskinson underscores the economic challenges Wyoming’s stablecoin could face, citing a modest $5.8 million budget and a rapidly shifting regulatory environment. He argues that established stablecoin issuers generate billions in revenue and can pivot quickly to acquire or adapt to new regulations, leaving little room for a nascent state-backed project to gain market traction.

霍斯金森（Hoskinson）在讲话中强调了怀俄明州的稳定者所面临的经济挑战，理由是预算不高，预算较小和迅速转移的监管环境。他认为，建立的Stablecoin发行人会产生数十亿美元的收入，并且可以迅速转移以获取或适应新的法规，几乎没有足够的空间来获得一个新生的国家支持的项目来获得市场吸引力。

“Tether made $13 billion last year. Circle made basically the same,” he notes, pointing out the intense competition. “You have a $5.8 million budget… and at the end of the day, you’re sitting on a CBDC in Wyoming.”

“系绳去年赚了130亿美元。他指出激烈的比赛基本上是相同的。 “您有580万美元的预算……归根结底，您坐在怀俄明州的CBDC上。”

He further questions why the state would not simply “white label” an existing stablecoin infrastructure rather than build from scratch, noting that negotiating a share of Treasury bill revenue or interest payments could theoretically benefit Wyoming without incurring large development costs.

他进一步质疑为什么国家不会简单地将现有的Stablecoin基础设施“白色标签”而不是从头开始建造，并指出谈判在理论上可以从理论上使怀俄明州受益于怀俄明州而不会产生大型开发成本。

Hoskinson, who lives in Wheatland, Wyoming, frames his criticism as a defense of local residents. He argues that public funds are being jeopardized in a venture that may fail to deliver a meaningful benefit to the state’s taxpayers. In his view, had the PRD been openly available—particularly the freeze-and-seize requirement—Cardano, among other platforms, would have submitted a bid more aligned with the state’s purported goals.

怀俄明州居住在惠特兰德的霍斯金森（Hoskinson）将他的批评作为对当地居民的辩护。他辩称，公共资金正在遭受危害，这可能无法为该州的纳税人带来有意义的利益。他认为，如果PRD公开可用（尤其是冻结要求），卡尔达诺（Cardano）除其他平台外，还将提出与该州所谓的目标更加一致的竞标。

“They don’t deserve that,” he says of Wyoming’s workforce. “This is not how procurement works… not how anybody should operate.” He calls on officials, including state legislators, to

他谈到怀俄明州的劳动力时说：“他们不值得。” “这不是采购的运作方式……不是任何人应该如何运作。”他呼吁包括州议员在内的官员