Coinbase 在 Celo 第 2 層遷移之前下架 CGLD，社群批評這項決定

加密貨幣交易所 Coinbase 宣布將於 2025 年 1 月 13 日下架並停止支援 Celo 第 1 層區塊鏈代幣 CGLD。

Crypto exchange Coinbase has announced that it will delist and stop supporting Celo layer-1 blockchain token (CGLD) by January 13, 2025. This move is in response to Celo’s planned migration into a layer-2 network.

加密貨幣交易所 Coinbase 宣布將於 2025 年 1 月 13 日下架並停止支援 Celo 第 1 層區塊鏈代幣 (CGLD)。

According to Coinbase Assets’ announcement, the migration will not be supported, and customers holding CGLD on Coinbase must withdraw it before it becomes inaccessible. The announcement noted that the Celo Layer-1 network will cease to be functional.

根據Coinbase Assets的公告，將不支援遷移，在Coinbase上持有CGLD的客戶必須在無法存取之前將其撤回。該公告指出，Celo 第 1 層網路將停止運作。

“Celo L1 network will stop producing blocks and customers will no longer be able to send or receive assets on the Celo L1 network. All funds remaining on Coinbase will become inaccessible, and must be withdrawn before January 13, 2025.”

「Celo L1 網路將停止生產區塊，客戶將無法再在 Celo L1 網路上發送或接收資產。 Coinbase 上剩餘的所有資金將無法使用，並且必須在 2025 年 1 月 13 日之前提取。

The exchange further noted that users can move the token to other wallets and exchanges, stipulating that most wallets list the token as CELO. Thus, users can simply move CGLD to any wallet that is compatible with CELO. Following the announcement, CELO price fell by 5%, dropping to $0.813.

該交易所進一步指出，用戶可以將代幣轉移到其他錢包和交易所，規定大多數錢包將代幣列為CELO。因此，用戶可以簡單地將 CGLD 轉移到任何與 CELO 相容的錢包中。消息公佈後，CELO 價格下跌 5%，跌至 0.813 美元。

Celo is an L1 blockchain that is compatible with the Ethereum Virtual Machine (EVM). It recently finalized plans to migrate into L2, which its developer, cLabs, believes will make the network more sustainable.

Celo 是一個與以太坊虛擬機器 (EVM) 相容的 L1 區塊鏈。它最近敲定了遷移到 L2 的計劃，其開發商 cLabs 認為這將使網路更具可持續性。

Crypto community criticizes Coinbase decisionCoinbase's decision to halt support for Celo has triggered an avalanche of reaction from the crypto community, with many describing it as antithetical to Coinbase's mission. Mento Labs engineering partner Philip Paetz noted that this could demotivate other chains planning to become L2.

加密社群批評 Coinbase 的決定 Coinbase 停止支持 Celo 的決定引發了加密社群的強烈反應，許多人認為這與 Coinbase 的使命背道而馳。 Mento Labs 工程合作夥伴 Philip Paetz 指出，這可能會打擊其他計劃成為 L2 的連鎖店。

“Sad to see coinbase dropping Celo. Feels at odds with their mission to increase economic freedom in the world, guess that only applies for Base. Also demotivating for other chains thinking about becoming an L2 on Ethereum.”

「很遺憾看到 coinbase 放棄了 Celo。感覺與他們增加世界經濟自由的使命不一致，我猜這只適用於基地。這也讓其他想要成為以太坊 L2 的區塊鏈失去了動力。

Marek Olszewski, the CEO of cLabs, also agreed with this view, noting that it is disheartening and seems like a “wrench in Ethereum’s Layer-2 centric scaling roadmap” because other EVM-compatible L1s will now think twice about transitioning to L2 if it means losing Coinbase support.

cLabs 執行長Marek Olszewski 也同意這一觀點，並指出這是令人沮喪的，並且似乎是“以太坊以Layer-2 為中心的擴展路線圖的一個扳手”，因為如果其他EVM 兼容的L1 現在會在過渡到L2 時三思而後行。

Others, such as crypto investor Alex Witt, believe Celo should enjoy migration support, especially since it uses the OP stack, the same technology supporting Coinbase L2 Base. They noted that Coinbase already supports Base, which is part of the OP Superchain, and should be able to easily implement similar support rails for Celo. As Ethereum L2 bull Patrick McCorry noted, there is no point in joining the Superchain if there will be no migration support.

其他人，例如加密貨幣投資者 Alex Witt，認為 Celo 應該享受遷移支持，特別是因為它使用 OP 堆疊，與支持 Coinbase L2 Base 的技術相同。他們指出，Coinbase 已經支援 Base，它是 OP Superchain 的一部分，並且應該能夠輕鬆地為 Celo 實現類似的支援軌道。正如以太坊 L2 牛市 Patrick McCorry 指出的那樣，如果沒有遷移支持，加入超級鏈就沒有意義。

Community calls on Coinbase to reconsider its stance as Kraken announces support for Celo migrationMeanwhile, Olszewski has proposed a solution: Celo Layer-1 validators can keep the current L1 and rename it to Celo Gold (CGLD) so that Coinbase can continue listing the token, possibly as a memecoin. By doing this, he believes that Coinbase can later support the migrating Layer-2 and list CELO as a token on its exchange.

隨著Kraken 宣布支持Celo 遷移，社群呼籲Coinbase 重新考慮其立場，同時Olszewski 提出了一個解決方案：Celo Layer-1 驗證器可以保留目前的L1 並將其重命名為Celo Gold (CGLD)，以便Coinbase 可以繼續列出代幣，可能作為迷因幣。透過這樣做，他相信 Coinbase 以後可以支援遷移 Layer-2，並將 CELO 作為其交易所的代幣列出。

Milk Road owner Kyle Reidhead also noted that Base, not Coinbase, is part of the OP Superchain. He observed that Coinbase likely did not consider the Superchain in making its decision but expected the exchange to change its position, saying:

Milk Road 所有者 Kyle Reidhead 也指出，Base（而不是 Coinbase）是 OP 超級鏈的一部分。他觀察到，Coinbase 在做出決定時可能沒有考慮超級鏈，但預計該交易所會改變立場，他說：

“I’m sure it’s just a typical process and they need time to audit / review. No need to get up and arms here everyone – especially no need to FUD the superchain.”

「我確信這只是一個典型的流程，他們需要時間進行審核/審查。每個人都不需要站起來武裝起來——尤其不需要對超級鏈感到恐懼。

Many other stakeholders seem to share this view, including Daily Gwei founder Anthony Sassano, who believes it is an internal communications issue and hopes Coinbase can reverse its position. EigenLayer founder Sreeram Kannan also shares a similar view, describing it as an internal oversight.

許多其他利害關係人似乎也同意這一觀點，包括 Daily Gwei 創辦人 Anthony Sassano，他認為這是一個內部溝通問題，並希望 Coinbase 能夠扭轉立場。 EigenLayer 創辦人 Sreeram Kannan 也持有類似觀點，將其描述為內部監督。

With many in the Ethereum community backing Celo, one of Coinbase's major competitors, Kraken, has openly declared support for Celo migration. Andrew Koller, the founder of Kraken L2 Ink which is part of the OP Superchain, said the exchange is committed to Ethereum scaling.

由於以太坊社群中有許多人支援 Celo，Coinbase 的主要競爭對手之一 Kraken 也公開宣布支援 Celo 遷移。 Kraken L2 Ink 是 OP Superchain 的一部分，其創始人 Andrew Koller 表示，該交易所致力於以太坊擴容。

“Kraken and Ink 💜 the superchain and are fully committed to Ethereum scaling and making Kraken work for Celo users. We’ve asked the relevant teams to explore this to see if we can hit everything in time for Jan. 16th – stay tuned!”

「Kraken 和 Ink 💜 超級鏈完全致力於以太坊擴展並使 Kraken 為 Celo 用戶服務。我們已經要求相關團隊對此進行探索，看看我們是否能夠在 1 月 16 日之前及時完成所有任務——敬請期待！

Still, some industry experts believe Coinbase's decision might be justified. Former a16z crypto executive Nass Eddequiouaq noted that technical, regulatory, and operational considerations come with supporting a new chain. He noted that Coinbase might just be waiting to see how the hard fork plays out before choosing which iteration of the Celo network to support.

儘管如此，一些行業專家認為 Coinbase 的決定可能是合理的。 a16z 加密貨幣前高階主管 Nass Eddequiouaq 指出，支援新鏈需要考慮技術、監管和營運方面的考量。他指出，Coinbase 可能只是在等待硬分叉的效果，然後再選擇支援哪一個 Celo 網路迭代。

Meanwhile, Coinbase has clarified its statement, debunking claims that it does not support other L1 and L2 networks. In a post on X, the exchange stated that it intends to be a bridge to the crypto economy. According to Coinbase, although it does

同時，Coinbase 澄清了其聲明，駁斥了其不支持其他 L1 和 L2 網路的說法。該交易所在 X 上的一篇貼文中表示，它打算成為通往加密經濟的橋樑。根據 Coinbase 的說法，儘管它確實