預挖掘超節點分佈提出了有關PI Network的權力下放承諾的問題

一個聲稱代表團隊的帳戶做出了回應，但答案因模糊而受到批評，僅解釋了超節點的技術作用，而無需詳細說明用戶如何操作它們。

A post on Reddit has brought to light some concerns regarding Pi Network, with users reporting a lack of token rewards for several months and skepticism over the platform's decentralization claims.

Reddit上的一篇文章對PI網絡提出了一些擔憂，用戶報告了幾個月缺乏令牌獎勵，並且對該平台的權力下放主張的持懷疑態度。

The post, which was made by a user asking for someone running a Node or SuperNode to explain what it is and share their experience, has sparked a discussion among node operators who say they have not been receiving any Pi token rewards for months.

該帖子是由用戶提出的，要求某人運行節點或超級節點來解釋其是什麼並分享他們的經驗，並引發了節點運營商的討論，他們說他們已經數月了幾個月都沒有獲得任何PI代幣獎勵。

"I have been running a Pi node for over a year now and I can confirm that I have not received any Pi token rewards for the past 6 months," one node operator wrote.

一位節點運營商寫道：“我已經運行了一個PI節點已有一年多了，我可以確認過去6個月沒有收到任何PI代幣獎勵。”

Another user, who claims to have been operating a SuperNode for the past six months, said they had only received a small amount of Pi tokens in the beginning.

另一位聲稱過去六個月一直在操作超級節點的用戶說，他們一開始只收到了少量的PI令牌。

"I am still running my SuperNode and I am not planning to stop anytime soon. However, I am starting to get a bit worried because I have not received any Pi token rewards for the past few months. I am also starting to suspect that only those with insider connections or high-end hardware are able to qualify for the Pi token rewards, which goes against Pi Network's claim of being 'a cryptocurrency for everyone'," the user wrote.

“我仍在運行超級節點，我不打算很快停止。但是，我開始感到有些擔心，因為過去幾個月我沒有收到任何PI代幣獎勵。我也開始懷疑只有那些擁有內部連接或高端硬件的人才能為Pi Token獎勵提供資格，這與PI網絡有資格違反PIKENTECT，這是對Pi network work of the of the of erseclence of erseclence of erseclence of the cyptocer的申請。

These concerns have also fueled skepticism about whether token distribution is still centrally controlled, undermining decentralization claims.

這些擔憂也引起了人們對是否仍受到集中控制的代幣分佈的懷疑，破壞了權力下放的主張。

"I am starting to think that the token distribution is still centrally controlled and that the SuperNode program is just a way to collect data on node operators and siphon off their computing power."

“我開始認為令牌分佈仍然受到集中控制，超級節點程序只是一種收集節點運算符和虹吸能量的數據的方式。”

Several users suspect that the lack of token rewards may be due to a technical issue that the Pi Core Team is currently trying to resolve.

一些用戶懷疑缺乏令牌獎勵可能是由於PI Core團隊目前正在嘗試解決的技術問題。

"I am sure that the Pi Core Team is aware of the issue and they are working hard to fix it. I am also confident that all node operators will eventually receive the Pi token rewards that they are due."

“我相信PI Core團隊已經意識到了這個問題，他們正在努力解決問題。我也相信所有節點運營商最終都會獲得他們應得的PI令牌獎勵。”

Earlier reports:

較早的報告：

- Ben Zhou calls Pi Network a scam project

- 本週將pi網絡稱為騙局項目

- Pi Network mainnet launch sparks mixed reactions

-PI網絡主網發射火花混合反應

- Pi Network to cooperate with Chainlink for interoperability

-PI網絡與鍊鍊鏈接合作以互操作性

Pi Nodes are desktop applications that help create and store Pi.

PI節點是有助於創建和存儲PI的桌面應用程序。

According to the official website, Pi Node is a program that users can download and run on their computer to contribute to the network and earn Pi tokens.

根據官方網站，PI節點是一個程序，用戶可以在其計算機上下載並運行以促進網絡並賺取PI令牌。

Unlike the smartphone app, which handles registration, login and daily check-in, Pi Nodes also validate blockchain transactions.

與處理註冊，登錄和每日入住的智能手機應用程序不同，PI節點還驗證了區塊鏈交易。

Unlike Bitcoin and Ethereum, which use proof-of-work algorithms that reward computational effort, Pi relies on the Stellar Consensus Protocol (SCP). SCP allows nodes to form "security circles" with trusted peers and validate only transactions approved by others in the group. Nodes are expected to stay online as much as possible to ensure reliability.

與比特幣和以太坊不同，使用了獎勵計算工作的工作證明算法，PI依賴於出色的共識協議（SCP）。 SCP允許節點與值得信賴的同齡人形成“安全圈”，並僅驗證小組中其他人批准的交易。預計節點將盡可能保持在線，以確保可靠性。

The Pi Network mobile app features an introduction to Pi Node version 0.5.0. Photo by VnExpress/Hoang Anh

PI網絡移動應用程序具有PI節點版本0.5.0的簡介。 vnexpress/hoang anh攝

In an update released in early March, PCT introduced the SuperNode. According to the Pi Network website it is "the backbone of Pi’s Blockchain."

在3月初發布的更新中，PCT引入了超級節點。根據PI網絡網站，它是“ Pi的區塊鏈的骨幹”。

They are responsible for reaching a consensus based on the algorithm to write the right transaction on the Pi ledger, in addition to all the responsibilities that a node performs. They’re also responsible for making sure other SuperNodes and Nodes get the latest state of the blockchain.

除了節點履行的所有責任外，他們還負責基於算法在PI Ledger上編寫正確的交易。他們還負責確保其他超節點和節點獲得區塊鏈的最新狀態。

SuperNodes also utilize the node interface and are initially selected by the Core Team. They need to be connected to the network 24/7 and have a reliable internet connection.

超節點還使用節點接口，最初是由核心團隊選擇的。他們需要連接到24/7網絡並具有可靠的Internet連接。

A new debate has emerged around Pi Network’s SuperNode, with many questioning whether the platform is genuinely decentralized or merely a centrally controlled system, according to CoinPedia.

根據Coinpedia的說法，圍繞PI Network的超節點已經出現了一場新的辯論，許多人質疑該平台是真正的分散還是僅僅是中央控制的系統。

Unlike Bitcoin and Ethereum, which rely on thousands of independently operated nodes, Pi Network remains under close management by its development team. PiScan data shows that initially only three SuperNodes operated, all run by the core team in Canada and Finland. While that number has grown to 42, transparency remains an issue, with limited information shared publicly.

與比特幣和以太坊（依賴數千個獨立運行的節點）不同，PI網絡仍在其開發團隊的密切管理中。 Piscan數據顯示，最初只有三個超節點由加拿大和芬蘭的核心團隊運行。儘管這個數字已增長到42個，但透明度仍然是一個問題，並且公開共享信息有限。

“With so few validators, decision-making power is limited to a select few, making the network significantly more centralized than its competitors,” Brave New Coin commented.

“由於驗證者很少，決策能力僅限於少數幾個，這使得網絡比競爭對手更為集中，” Brave New Coin評論道。

PiScan data further indicates that 62.8 billion Pi coins are stored in six wallets controlled by PCT, with another 20 billion held across nearly 10,000 unlisted wallets linked to the team. “This means that just a small group of insiders controls the majority of the supply, leaving little room for true decentralization,” Brave New Coin said.

Piscan的數據進一步表明，有628億枚PI硬幣存儲在由PCT控制的六個錢包中，另外2000億個與該團隊相關的未列出錢包。 Brave New Coin說：“這意味著只有一小群內部人員控制著大部分供應，幾乎沒有真正的權力下放的空間。”

The Pi Network team has not responded to these concerns.

PI網絡團隊尚未回應這些問題。

In a series of nine posts on X (formerly Twitter), Justin Bons, founder and CIO of Cyber Capital, openly called Pi Network a scam.

在X（以前為Twitter）上的一系列九個帖子中，網絡資本的創始人兼CIO Justin Bons公開稱為PI Network是騙局。

“WARNING: PI is a straight-up scam!” Bons wrote on March 20.

“警告：PI是一個直截了當的騙局！”邦斯在3月20日寫道。

“Offering an ‘MLM’ based ‘mining’ scheme on mobile is a gimmick, as it does not contribute to consensus! PI is fully permissioned (centralized) & everything requires KYC, even

“在移動設備上提供基於'MLM'的'挖掘'計劃是一種頭，因為它沒有促進共識！PI是完全許可的（集中式），一切都需要KYC，甚至需要KYC