9 Significant Gotham Storylines That Ultimately Went Nowhere, Leaving Unanswered Questions About the DC Series

Gotham is known for its ambitious narratives and bold reimaginings of Batman's origin and the DCU timeline. It featured numerous gripping narratives, yet some of the most intriguing were abandoned or forgotten about. From unresolved character arcs to dropped teases of iconic villains, the show left many threads dangling.

Gotham, a prequel series to the Batman universe, followed the early years of Jim Gordon and Bruce Wayne as they navigated the crime-ridden city. Despite its ambitious storytelling and bold reimaginings, the show ultimately left several significant storylines unresolved, sparking questions among fans.

1. The Man-Bat Tease:

In the season 4 finale, a montage of new Gotham villains glimpsed a winged humanoid figure, teasing the introduction of Man-Bat. However, the mysterious creature was never addressed again in the final season. Given the show's love for exploring Gotham's bizarre and supernatural elements, Man-Bat seemed like a perfect addition to the narrative.

2. Thomas Wayne's Used Bulletproof Vest:

In season 2, Bruce Wayne and Alfred discover a hidden office in Wayne Manor, revealing a bulletproof vest with a bullet hole that had belonged to Thomas Wayne. The discovery hinted at a deeper mystery surrounding Thomas's life and the possible dangers he faced before his murder. However, this intriguing detail was never elaborated upon in subsequent episodes.

3. The Executioner Escapes:

Nathaniel Barnes, a former GCPD captain, became a version of the DC villain, the Executioner. After succumbing to the effects of the Tetch virus, Barnes becomes a murderous vigilante targeting Gotham's criminals. He is captured by Gordon and Bullock and sent to Arkham Asylum. However, during his transfer, Barnes escapes custody, leaving his fate unresolved.

4. Sofia Falcone Survives And Returns To Gotham:

Sofia Falcone's arc in Gotham season 4 ended with a dramatic twist: she survived being shot in the head by Lee Thompkins, who was trying to protect Jim Gordon. The dialogue surrounding her survival heavily implied that Sofia would return to seek revenge or reclaim her family's power. However, she never reappeared in the series.

5. Harvey Dent Becomes Two-Face:

Harvey Dent's transformation into Two-Face is one of the most iconic arcs in Batman lore, but Gotham never fully explored it. Introduced as a recurring character in season 1 and promoted to series regular in season 2, Dent played a minor role in the show's narrative. Despite his potential, the character was gradually sidelined and eventually disappeared altogether.